Thursday, March 5, 2015

Adapting Book

For P.S. I Love You, I think it being made into a movie was the best choice however I think a t.v. show could have worked too. I think it would make a good short series t.v. show because each episode could be a new letter Holly receives from Gerry. I think Gerry`s funeral would be essential to keep in the film so you know he died and I think Holly receiving every letter is essential because that's basically the plot line of the whole story. I think the man Holly falls in love with in the movie could be cut because in the book Holly is more focused on Gerry`s death rather than falling in love with a man who works in her mom`s bar which also doesn't exist in the book. In the book, Holly has a big family. Holly`s parents are still married and she has lots of siblings and her family lives on the beach rather than in the city. I think that this was a huge part of the plot in the book and it needs to be added to the movie because the movie was lacking background information of Holly, her family, and Gerry. Basically in the movie there`s one fight with Gerry alive then it jumps right to his funeral and I didn't like that at all.  I wanted more backstory on them as a couple in the movie. I would cast Channing Tatum as Gerry instead of Gerard Butler because he is younger and more buff (as Gerry is described in the book) and since everyone else in the movie was American I think Gerry should be too. The movie basically changed the whole plot and almost story of the book. For Holly, I would cast Dianna Agron from Glee because she is young and blonde and really skinny as Holly is described in the book. As far as the soundtrack for the movie goes, I would have a really depressing soundtrack for the beginning and throughout because Holly never fully climbs out of that depression. In some parts, I would have upbeat music when she starts to venture out or she sees her family. When she opens Gerry`s letters I would bring it back to depressing because she`s so happy when she gets them yet they rip her apart because she knows they won`t last forever and he`s never coming back. Overall, I think the book was transitioned into the movie poorly and I think it would be better if they redid it all together.

1 comment:

  1. I like the actors you chose to play the characters in the movie. I would definitely go see it :)

    ReplyDelete