Prompt A:
When reading Daryn Kagan`s Your Rattle No One Else Can Hear? it really spoke to me. This column had to do with much more than a car rattle and that's when I connected it back to Catcher in the Rye- specifically Holden holding onto Allie`s baseball mitt. Allie`s baseball mitt was almost Holden`s rattle in a sense that which he held onto it and it carried him with the memory of his brother`s death. A simple rattle that was occurring in her car made her look at the bigger picture of life in which everyone has something that maybe not everyone can see or hear but she is validating that presence of a rattle in everyone`s life.
"As I continue to stress about the mystery rattle, it strikes me, Dear Reader, you just might have a rattle, as well.
Maybe not in your kinda, newish car. Rather, that thing that is the thorn in your side, that others can’t see or detect that you’re told to get over.
The heartbreak you should be passed already.
The chronic pain that doesn’t go away from a long ago injury.
The brain injury that doesn’t show on the outside, but completely rewired you and your life forever.
The cancer you survived, but leaves you feeling unsettled.
Your rattle." (Kagan)
These couple of sentences from Kagan`s column made me think of Holden. He is a very complex character and has many sides to him in which its hard for people to uncover because he is so deep at such an intense level. Holden in my opinion has many rattles in which no one sees or hears. " ... I wrote about my brother Allie`s baseball mitt. It was a very descriptive subject. It really was. My brother Allie had this left-handed fielder`s mitt.... He got leukemia and died when we were up in Maine, on July 18, 1946." (Salinger 43) Allie`s death is Holden`s rattle because he will always carry it with him and a part of him will never be able to get over Allie and the sentimental baseball mitt of his that Holden will always have fond memories of.
you did a quality job! how can you personally relate to either or both of these excerpts?
ReplyDeleteI also think that Holden is a very deep character and must have a lot of rattles that we haven't unraveled yet, besides his brothers death. What other rattles, or pains do you think Holden has, that makes him act the way he does?
ReplyDeleteI also think the part about how this "rattle" that no one else sees in Holden is essential in creating his character. No one knows what Holden has went through because he thinks no one actually cares about how he feels, so because of this he is not able to establish any close relationships with people. He comes off as not caring about anything but really he cares a great deal. I think this bottling up of emotions causes him to have severe and sudden outbursts as shown in his fight with Stradlater. Holden may have had a valid reason for this outburst but because Holden doesn't voice his opinion, to Stradlater it seemed as if he got all worked up for no good reason. What do you think this will come of as we move closer to the end of the book? Will his emotions get the best of him cause for a catastrophic downfall?
ReplyDeleteGelina- I think Holden`s rattles have a lot to do with Allie`s death and how he pushes everyone away. he doesn't like to get too close to people because he fears losing them.
ReplyDelete